[GushShalom] From the Israeli madhouse: re Belgians & court-martialed COs

[Gush Shalom (Israeli Peace Bloc)]

/////////////////
     Gush Shalom               International release, Feb.24
     /////////////////////////          

[] When A kidnaps in B the citizen of C... Uri Avnery in this weeks article

[] Army panicking? COs court-martialed one after the other

--Uri Ya'acobi, third CO to be court-martialed
--Dror Boymel back to Conscience Committee
--Adam Maor - 28 days
--WRI calls for delegation to Israel 

                                \\//
                                //\\

[Yesterday, five Palestinians killed during the reoccupation of Beit Hanoun 
in the Gaza Strip. One Israeli soldier killed while guarding a settlement a bit 
further south. This morning the announcement of 25 Palestinians arrested 
during the night and taken off to interrogation by the security services (and 
all what it means). Meanwhile, Sharon puts the finishing touch on his new 
government coalition (thank God not including the Labor Party).
   In Uri Avnery's defence of the decision of the Belgian court you also get a 
sense of the Israeli establishment's outrage. And how much they feel 
threatened by a dozen young boys with the courage to follow their 
conscience comes after it.]

[] When A kidnaps in B the citizen of C... Uri Avnery in this weeks article

Uri Avnery
22.3.03

                              It's OK to Eat Belgian Chocolate

     "Don't eat Belgian chocolate," the Israel consul in Florida ordered the 
large Jewish community there.
     In Israel, anti-Belgian curses reached an ear-splitting new crescendo. 
Miserable Belgium! Mad Belgium! Megalomaniac Belgium! And again and 
again, Anti-Semitic Belgium! Neo-Nazi Belgium! 
     The Israeli ambassador was, of course, recalled from Brussels. No 
wonder, how can Israel keep an ambassador in the world capital of anti-
Semitism?  
     The storm broke when a Belgian court decided that Ariel Sharon can be 
sued for alleged war crimes, but only after finishing his term as Prime 
Minister of Israel. Israel army officers connected with the 1982 massacre in 
the Sabra and Shatila refugee camps can be sued even now.
     On an Israeli TV program, the anchorman, a lawyer, put it this way: 
"Anti-Semitic Belgium wants to judge the officers of a second country for 
crimes committed in a third country, while the accused have no connection 
at all with Belgium, are not on Belgium territory and the whole affair does 
not concern Belgium. That is megalomania, really a matter for 
psychiatrists!" 
     "Strange," I replied on the program, "I seem to remember a case where 
country A kidnapped in country B the citizen of country C for committing in 
country D crimes against the citizens of countries E, F and G, all this in 
spite of the fact the crimes were committed before country A even existed."
      I meant, of course, the trial of Adolf Eichmann, to which we all agreed.
     "How can you compare the two!" the other participants on the program 
cried out in outraged unison. And indeed, how can one compare the actions 
of Jews with actions of goyim committed against Jews?
     Well, it were the Jews who demanded, after World War II, that all 
countries put Nazi war criminals and their allies on trial. Eichmann was 
judged in Israel according to the Israeli "Law for bringing the Nazis and their 
Helpers to Justice", which does not recognize any borders. More recently 
the Knesset enacted another law, enabling Israeli courts to judge 
perpetrators of any crime committed against Jews anywhere in the world. If 
so, what's wrong with the Belgian law of "universal jurisdiction", that allows 
Belgian courts to judge was criminals from all over the world?
     Immanuel Kant promulgated the Categorical Imperative: "Act as if the 
principle by which you act were about to be turned into a universal law of 
nature".  But then, Kant was probably an anti-Semite.
     Hundreds of years ago, the world adopted a legal doctrine that allowed 
every country to judge and hang pirates, irrespective of their ethnic identity, 
origin and area of activity. The assumption was that the pirate is an enemy 
of humanity at large, and that therefore every country has the right – indeed, 
the duty – to judge him.
     The Belgian law against war crimes is a step in this direction, and I hope 
that many other countries will follow suit. Of course, it would be better if the 
International Criminal Court in The Hague would fulfil this duty, but much 
time will pass before it will be able to. Immense political pressures are 
being exerted, many limitations have been imposed, its hands and feet have 
been shackled. Worse, the only super-power, the United States, is openly 
trying to destroy it (as it destroyed the League of Nations after World War I.)
     My dream is that before the end of the 21st century a new, binding world 
order, headed by a world parliament, will come into being. This order must 
include a world court and a world police force, that will judge conflicts 
between nations the way today's national courts judge conflicts between 
people. The road there is long and full of obstacles, decades will pass 
before humanity will reach this stage. But we must strive towards this end. 
In the meantime, other countries must follow the Belgian example, in order 
to progress along this way. Especially concerning war crimes.
     Some will say that we should not extradite our fellow-citizens, that it is 
the duty of every state to judge its war-criminals itself. But this is utopian: 
no country in the world has really done so. That is quite natural: not only 
are states disinclined to admit to such shameful crimes and try to hide 
them, but generally such crimes are committed by agents of the state itself. 
     The affair of Sabra and Shatila is a good example. Here, briefly, are the 
facts:
     In the summer of 1982, the Israeli army invaded West Beirut, violating an 
explicit commitment given to the American mediator, Phillip Habib, not to 
do so. By that time, the PLO forces had already left the city.
     From that moment on, West Beirut, including the Palestinian refugee 
camps Sabra and Shatila, became an Israeli occupied territory, making the 
Israeli army responsible for everything happening there.
     After the occupation, the IDF let the "Phalangists", members of an 
extreme Maronite Christian group, enter the two camps. These people has 
already committed heinous massacres in other Palestinian refugee camps. 
They were headed by a notorious mass-murderer, Eli Hweika.
     All senior Israeli officials involved with Lebanon knew that the 
Phalangists were committing atrocities in order to panic the Palestinians 
into fleeing from Lebanon.
     When the Israeli cabinet was informed of the army's intention of letting 
the Phalangists in, Minister David Levy, who was born in Morocco, warned 
that this would cause a disaster. His colleagues ignored his warning.
     Immediately upon entering the camps, the Phalangists started to 
butcher men, women and children indiscriminately.
     The commander of the action, Eli Hweika, oversaw the action from the 
roof of the Israeli divisional command post, which was located right next to 
the camps. The officers of the Israeli division commander, General Amos 
Yaron, overheard Hweika instructing his men by walkie-talkie to kill women 
and children, too. They hastened to inform Yaron, but he ignored the 
message. (Later he admitted: "Our senses had become blunted.")
     During the night, while the massacre was going on (it lasted altogether 
three days), the Israeli Chief-of-Staff, General Raphael Eytan, ordered the 
army to accede to the Phalangists' request and light the area with flares. He 
also provided the Phalangists with a tractor (which served, it is assumed, to 
bury the bodies).  
     A young Israeli officer who heard the horrible stories of the shocked 
women who had succeeded in fleeing from the camps, ran from one officer 
to another, begging them to interfere. All of them refused.
     After the massacre, the Begin government refused to order an 
independent investigation. In a huge demonstration in Tel-Aviv (the 
mythological 400-thousand-demo), we compelled the government to appoint 
a high-level state investigation committee, headed by Supreme Court judge 
Yitzhaq Kahan. It did a good job and its report included all the facts 
mentioned above. In its conclusions, it found that the Minister of Defense 
(Sharon), the Chief-of-Staff and a number of other senior officers bear 
"indirect responsibility" for the outrage. Some of us argued even then that 
the committee had bent backwards in order to protect the reputation of the 
state, and that from the same facts much more far-reaching conclusions 
could have been drawn.
     The committee recommended, inter alia, to dismiss the Minister of 
Defense from his office and to remove Yaron from the active command of 
troops in the field. But the committee did not recommend to dismiss Sharon 
altogether from the government and from public life, neither did it dismiss 
Yaron from the army. It did not take any step against the Chief-of-Staff, 
because he was about to finish his term anyhow. Other officers suffered 
minor penalties.
      Today, Sharon is Prime Minister, practically commanding the army and 
Amos Yaron is Director General of the Ministry of Defense. As a matter of 
fact, all those accused by the Kahan report have been promoted.
      Most importantly, not one of those suspected of responsibility for the 
massacre was ever put on trial (as distinguished from a commission of 
inquiry).
     After the enactment of the Belgian law of universal jurisdiction, the 
survivors of the massacre sued Sharon and the officers in Brussels. It's this 
case that has caused the present uproar.
      Nobody questions the integrity of the Belgian judicial system. If Sharon 
and his men are confident of their innocence, why shouldn't they stand trial 
and prove it? After all, the Israeli government has put at their disposal its 
senior attorneys, paid by the state. (One could ask, of course, why I should 
pay for the legal defense of people put on trial for alleged war crimes. But 
never mind.) 
     All this has nothing to do with anti-Semitism. The use of this defamation 
against everybody who dares to criticize Sharon and his colleagues reminds 
one of Dr. Samuel Johnson's sayings: "Patriotism is the last refuge of a 
scoundrel."
      So you may eat Belgian chocolate. Even if it is of the bitter kind.


[] Army panicking? COs court-martialed one after the other

--Uri Ya'acobi, third CO to be court-martialed
--Dror Boymel back to Conscience Committee
--Adam Maor - 28 days
--WRI calls for delegation to Israel 

--Uri Ya'acobi, third CO to be court-martialed. 
 
Immediately upon being released yesterday from a previous prison term, Uri 
Ya'acobi was taken by military police to the Induction Center and was told 
that it was "in order to be discharged from the army."  Upon arrival there it 
turned out that instead he will face a court martial, and thereupon was taken 
 immediately to Prison-4. Uri is due to have his preliminary hearing today     
 or tomorrow. The army doesn't give us much time to organize a presence, 
but we will let you know as soon as we know when and where.
STAY TUNED FOR ANOTHER  MESSAGE  LATER TODAY.


--Dror Boymel back to Conscience Committee
Yesterday, the ACRI legal team defending Dror Boymel who was last Friday 
imprisoned pending a court martial, succeeded to get for him a new 
heaaring by the (purely military) Conscience Committee which laast year 
rejected his claim to be a pacifist. Moreover, he was sent home pending 
that hearing. Adv. Michaael Sfard will now try to apply this precedent both 
to Uri Ya'acobi and to Yoni Ben Artzi, the first of the series.

--Adam Maor - 28 days
Also yesterday Adam Maor - who it seems did not yet accumulate enough 
repeated refusals for the honour to be court-martialed - waas sentenced to  
another 28 days, and was reported to be spending them at Prison-4 in the 
Isolation Ward. (Which heinous violation of prison regulations caused him to 
be consigned there, we don't know.) Another draft resister, Yoni Yechezkel 
was invited "to see a psychiatrist", but when he arrived at the Induction 
Center was told instead to (re)present himself to be drafted. Thereupon, he 
succeeded in leaving the center...

--WRI calls for delegation to Israel 

War Resisters' International <info at wri-irg.org> wrote:
 Date: Fri, 21 Feb 2003 11:40:35 +0000
 WRI calls for delegation to Israel to observe court-martial of COs
 
 Dear all,
 In an obvious change of policy, the Israeli military is now starting to  court-
martial conscientious objectors, after they already spent more than  150 
days in prison. Jonathan Ben-Artzi had his first hearing on Wednesday, and 
is now in "open detention" at the induction base awaiting court-martial. He 
already served 200 days in military prison - seven prison terms of 28-35 
days.
 Dror Boimel is presently serving his seventh prison term, after having 
served 168 days in prison. He too is now awaiting a  court-martial.
Unlike the usual disciplinary sentences of 28 or 35 days, a court-martial 
 can sentence Jonathan Ben-Artzi and Dror Boimel to up to three years 
 imprisonment for refusing to enlist. Other conscientious objectors are 
 presently serving repeated prison terms of 28 to 25 days, and they might 
 face court-martials too. More information on Jonathan Ben-Artzi and Dror 
 Boimel can be found at  http://wri-irg.org/news/htdocs/21022003a.html.
  It is therefore important that international delegations observe some of 
 the hearing of the court-martials - preferably at least on of the early 
 hearing, and the one which is expected to be the last. Hearing will happen 
 on relatively short notice (about 1 week), and we therefore need a pool of 
 potential delegates to draw from. Everybody who is willing to join a 
 delegation should contact the WRI Office immediately.
(mailto:concodoc at wri-irg.org, tel +44-20-72784040).
 
We will also need money to pay for travel and accomodation. Donations are
 therefore urgently needed. [For information how to do it from your country 
please, contact info at wri-irg.org.]
 
 Please contact the WRI Office as soon as possible.
 Israeli conscientious objectors now urgently need our support!
 
 Andreas Speck

War Resisters' International
5 Caledonian Road * London N1 9DX * BRITAIN
tel.: +44-20-7278 4040 * fax: +44-20-7278 0444
email: info at wri-irg.org * http://www.wri-irg.org 
In-depth about Israeli war resisters 
http://wri-irg.org/co/co-isr-03.htm


---
Photos of the Feb. 15 antiwar demonstrations worldwide 
http://www.hyperreal.org/~dana/
---
Protest against repeated and unlimited imprisonment of draft resisters at: 
http://www.petitiononline.com/091202/

---
On our site:
http://www.gush-shalom.org/ (òáøéú)
http://www.gush-shalom.org/english/index.html (English)

\\photo's - of action or otherwise informative 
\\the weekly Gush Shalom ad - in Hebrew and English 
\\the columns of Uri Avnery - in Hebrew, Arab and English
\\and an archive full of interesting documents

N.B.: 
On the Gush Shalom website links for:
Articles and documents in German
Articles and documents in French
Articles and documents in Spanish

In order to receive our Hebrew-language 
press releases [mostly WORD documents - 
not always same as English] mail to:
gush-shalom-heb-request at mailman.gush-shalom.org 
+ NB: write the word "subscribe" in the subject line.

To get forwarded reports and announcements which we receive + a 
selection of English-language articles, send one blank mail to: 
TOI_Billboard-subscribe at topica.com

If you want to support Gush Shalom's activities you can send a cheque or 
cash, wrapped well in an extra piece of paper to: 

Gush Shalom
pob 3322
Tel-Aviv 61033
Israel

or ask us for charities in your country which receive donations on behalf of 
Gush Shalom

Please, add your email address where to send our confirmation of receipt. 
More official receipts at request only.


NB: Via http://www.HelpPalestine.Org  you can donate from remote 
locations used but valuable goods. "Help Palestine" offers to take care of 
selling & transporting - profits to be sent to Palestine Red Crescent Society.